Three delicious ways to celebrate Thanksgiving with Prime Time Butcher.
Every family has a Thanksgiving dish that nobody else is allowed to make.
Maybe it’s Grandma’s stuffing. Maybe you’re the designated turkey roaster. Or maybe your favorite part is getting everyone around the table—and you’d happily hand over the cooking.
Our 2026 Thanksgiving menu has something for each kind of host. Keep the traditions you love, and choose where a little help would make the day easier.
Love Roasting the Turkey? Start Here.
There’s something satisfying about bringing a beautifully roasted turkey to the table, especially when it’s a tradition you look forward to all year.
Make our Fresh Whole Turkey the centerpiece of your table—choose cleaned and tied or unprepped. Prefer turkey breast? We also offer Bone-In and Boneless Turkey Breast.
Want a head start on flavor? Let us season your turkey with:
Herb Garlic: Rosemary, thyme, sage, fresh garlic, and extra virgin olive oil.
Citrus Herb: Orange slices, thyme, oregano, parsley, onion, garlic, and extra virgin olive oil.
Then leave a few sides to us. Pair your turkey with Yukon Mashed Potatoes, Apple, Apricot & Sausage Stuffing, Sautéed Broccoli, and Homemade Turkey Gravy.
You get your favorite cooking moment—and a little more room on the stovetop.
Our Herb-Roasted Sliced Turkey Breast, prepared with rosemary, thyme, sage, fresh garlic, and extra virgin olive oil, makes a delicious centerpiece alongside your family recipes.
Or roast your own turkey and let our kitchen take care of the sides:
Roasted Cornbread Stuffing brings old-fashioned holiday flavor.
Apple, Apricot & Sausage Stuffing combines tart green apples, sweet dried apricots, and savory pork sausage.
Yukon Mashed Potatoes and Sweet Mashed Potatoes deliver the comfort everyone expects.
Carrot Soufflé, a sweet, light, airy PTB favorite, gives guests something special to try.
Blowin’ Smoke Mac & Cheese earns its place with creamy macaroni and gooey cheeses baked to golden perfection.
Add Cranberry Fruit Compote, Cornbread, and Homemade Turkey Gravy for the finishing touches.
Build Your Own Thanksgiving Feast: Order your favorites individually—choose a main, a potato dish, a stuffing, a vegetable, and something bright or tangy. Then add the dish your family always asks for.
Want the Whole Dinner Taken Care Of?
Give yourself more time to enjoy the people you invited.
Our Scratch-Made Thanksgiving Dinner packages include:
Herb-Roasted Sliced Turkey Breast
Homemade Turkey Gravy
Yukon Mashed Potatoes
Sweet Mashed Potatoes
Roasted Cornbread Stuffing
Sautéed Broccoli
Cornbread
Cranberry Fruit Compote
Serves 4–6: $303.26
Serves 8–10: $567.18
Set the table, pick up dessert from your favorite bakery—or invite your guests to bring something sweet—and let us handle the heart of the meal.
Packages are offered as listed; substitutions and modifications are not available. Prices are subject to change based on current market conditions.
Make It Yours: Orange-Honey Butter
A small homemade touch can make the table feel extra special. This easy flavored butter is delicious alongside your cornbread.
Ingredients
½ cup softened unsalted butter
1 teaspoon finely grated orange zest
1 teaspoon honey
A pinch of salt, to taste
How to make it
Stir everything together, spoon into a serving bowl, cover, and refrigerate. Let it soften slightly before serving.
Looking Beyond Turkey?
There’s room for another centerpiece.
Choose a Prime Standing Rib Roast, Dry Aged Prime Filet Mignon Roast, or Honey-Orange Glazed Boneless Sliced & Tied Baked Ham from our butcher shop selections.
For prepared alternatives, try Lemon-Dill Roasted Salmon or Blowin’ Smoke Sliced Braised Brisket of Beef—prime dry-aged brisket smoked for 12 hours and BBQ-braised.
Our pairing idea: Brisket, Blowin’ Smoke Mac & Cheese, Roasted Yukon Potato Wedges, and a crisp green salad.
Let’s Plan Your Prime Time Thanksgiving
Whether you’re cooking the centerpiece, sharing the work, or ordering a complete dinner, we’re ready to help you put your menu together.
Orders must be received by November 17, 2026. Thanksgiving menu orders are for pickup only.
Call 516.921.6519 to Place Your Thanksgiving Order
Keep the traditions you love. Let us help with the rest.
