Thanksgiving at Prime Time
A little planning. A lot more celebrating.
Bring everyone to the table for a delicious holiday meal. Choose your main, add your favorite sides, and let Prime Time help you put it all together.
Plan Your Portions
Have your guest count ready, along with whether you want leftovers. Our team can help you choose your main and the right amount of sides.
Cooking & Reheating
Spend less time in the kitchen and more time at the table. Download our reheating guide for easy instructions to warm and serve your Thanksgiving favorites.
Don’t Forget the
Finishing Touches
Gravy for the turkey, stuffing to share, and something sweet to finish. Round out your Thanksgiving table with everyone’s holiday favorites.
Your neighborhood butcher
From our shop to your holiday table.
A Thanksgiving meal is more than its centerpiece. Find your main, stuffing, gravies, sides, and finishing touches below—and ask our team when you need a hand choosing.
Our StoryCooked Packages
Scratch-Made Thanksgiving Dinner – Serves 8-10$567.18- Scratch-Made Thanksgiving Dinner – Serves 4–6$303.26
Ultimate Hors D’oeuvres PackageFrom: $115.72
Build Your Thanksgiving Order
Jump to a category, choose your options, and add your favorites.
Cooked Mains Gravies & Stocks Side Dishes Stuffing Uncooked Mains Seafood
Cooked Mains
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | All Natural Bone-In Smoked Spiral Ham$94.10 | $94.10 | |
 | All Natural Boneless Sliced and Tied Smoked HamFrom: $69.64 | From: $69.64 | |
 | Cooked Lemon-Dill Salmon Fillet$77.43 | $77.43 | |
| | Herb-Roasted Sliced Turkey Breast$112.58 | $112.58 | |
 | Pulled Smoked Chicken$96.02 | $96.02 | |
 | Pulled Smoked Pork$96.02 | $96.02 | |
 | Sliced Smoked Braised Beef Brisket$174.68 | $174.68 | |
 | Smoked Baby Back Ribs$95.64 | $95.64 | |
 | Smoked St. Louis Spare Ribs$89.19 | $89.19 | |
Gravies & Stocks
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | Homemade Chicken Stock$16.78 | $16.78 | |
 | Homemade Turkey Gravy$16.78 | $16.78 | |
 | Homemade Turkey Stock$16.78 | $16.78 | |
Side Dishes
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | Carrot Souffle$35.17 | $35.17 | |
 | Cranberry Compote$28.94 | $28.94 | |
 | Homemade Macaroni & Cheese$66.95 | $66.95 | |
 | Roasted Potato Wedges$62.90 | $62.90 | |
 | Sauteed Broccoli$67.04 | $67.04 | |
 | Sweet Cornbread$14.75 | $14.75 | |
 | Sweet Mashed Potatoes$71.18 | $71.18 | |
 | Yukon Mashed Potatoes$71.18 | $71.18 | |
Stuffing
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | Apple, Apricot and Sausage Stuffing$83.60 | $83.60 | |
 | Roasted Cornbread Stuffing$79.46 | $79.46 | |
Uncooked Mains
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | All Natural Bone-In Turkey BreastFrom: $126.34 | From: $126.34 | |
 | All Natural Bone-In Turkey Thighs$22.11 | $22.11 | |
 | All Natural Boneless Turkey RoastFrom: $56.75 | From: $56.75 | |
 | All Natural Turkey Drumsticks$17.47 | $17.47 | |
 | All Natural Whole Fresh TurkeyFrom: $5.69 | From: $5.69 | |
 | Dry Aged Prime Filet Mignon RoastFrom: $242.11 | From: $242.11 | |
 | Dry Aged Prime Prime Time Sirloin Roast BeefFrom: $142.30 | From: $142.30 | |
 | Dry Aged Prime Standing Rib RoastFrom: $427.98 | From: $427.98 | |
 | Premium Angus Boneless New York Strip-Shell RoastFrom: $127.32 | From: $127.32 | |
 | Premium Angus Boneless Rib RoastFrom: $144.22 | From: $144.22 | |
 | Premium Angus Filet Mignon RoastFrom: $206.61 | From: $206.61 | |
 | Premium Angus Prime Time Sirloin Roast BeefFrom: $78.61 | From: $78.61 | |
 | Premium Angus Rib RoastFrom: $179.87 | From: $179.87 | |
| | Prime Standing Rib RoastFrom: $277.16 | From: $277.16 | |
 | Stuffed Capon Breast with Veggie Stuffing$94.12 | $94.12 | |
Seafood
| Product | Price | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 | Butterflied Branzino$11.28 | $11.28 | |
 | Faroe Island SalmonFrom: $19.55 | From: $19.55 | |
 | Fillet of Sole$25.34 | $25.34 | |
 | Flounder Fillet$25.34 | $25.34 | |
 | Medium Cold-Water Wild Lobster Tails 8oz/10oz$26.10 | $26.10 | |
 | Swordfish Steak$17.51 | $17.51 | |
 | Tail-On Peeled & Deveined Big Gulf Shrimp (6/8)$32.45 | $32.45 | |
 | Tail-On Peeled & Deveined White ShrimpFrom: $11.84 | From: $11.84 | |
 | Wild Atlantic Cod Fillet$17.51 | $17.51 | |
 | Wild Atlantic Halibut Fillet$25.33 | $25.33 | |
 | Wild Chilean Sea Bass Fillet$45.45 | $45.45 | |
 | Wild Tilapia Fillets$7.78 | $7.78 | |
 | Wild Tuna Steak$23.39 | $23.39 | |
A HAND WITH THE HOLIDAY
Your Thanksgiving questions, answered.
What size main should I choose?
Plan on about ½ pound of meat and ½ pound of side dishes per person, total across your selections. When offering several different dishes, choose enough of each so everyone can enjoy a taste. For bigger appetites or leftovers, order a little extra. Our team can help you choose the right quantities for your gathering.
Which items are cooked or uncooked?
The main dishes are grouped into Cooked Mains and Uncooked Mains. Check the individual product information and ask our team if you are unsure about any item’s preparation.
Where can I get cooking or reheating instructions?
Ask our team for instructions specific to the items in your order. Preparation can vary by product and size, so confirm your instructions before the holiday.
When can I pick up my order?
Confirm your holiday pickup date, time, and location with our team. Call 516.921.6519 for current arrangements and holiday hours.
Can you help with ingredient or dietary questions?
Contact our team about the specific dishes you are considering before ordering so we can help you check ingredients and preparation details.
Make the most of the leftovers
Give turkey a second act in a sandwich with cranberry sauce, and save a place for your favorite sides at tomorrow’s table.
Need a hand planning your holiday meal? Call 516.921.6519.
